regional etiketine sahip kayıtlar gösteriliyor. Tüm kayıtları göster
regional etiketine sahip kayıtlar gösteriliyor. Tüm kayıtları göster

30 Mart 2011 Çarşamba

Theoretical Studies on the Effects of Regional Integration

Theoretical Studies on the Effects of Regional Integration

As it is stated, theory on the welfare effects of regional economic integration stems from
Viner’s (1950) “The Customs Union Issue”. Prior to  this study, the customs union was
seen as a movement toward free trade and as a way to increase world welfare. As the father
of the concepts of trade creation and trade diversion, Viner had showed that the formation
of customs union was not necessarily a welfare improving process. While trade creation
effect arises in the case of “one of the members of the customs union will now newly
import from the other but which it formerly did not import at all because the price of the
protected domestic product was lower than the price at any foreign source plus the duty”,
trade diversion effect arises in the case of “one of the members of the customs union will
now newly import from the other whereas before the customs union it imported them from
a third country, because that was the cheapest possible source of supply even after payment
of duty” (Viner, 1950, p.43). Accordingly, net welfare effect of customs union will depend
on the extent of these two effects. For a customs union to operate in the free trade
direction, Viner (1950, p.51) suggests the larger economic area, the lower average tariff
level on post integration imports from non members, the less degree of complementarity of
the member countries with respect to protected industries, etc.

The analysis presented in Viner (1950) had been critized from several points, and resulted
in extensions on the issue.  For example, Lancaster and Lipsey (1956 57) take the Vinerian
analysis as “The General Theory of the Second Best”. In this theory, if it is impossible to
satisfy all of the optimum conditions, then a change in some of these conditions could
cause better or worse outcomes (cited in Lipsey, 1960, p.498). In addition to this, they
criticize the Vinerian analysis further due to its focus on the trade shifts from one country
to another and its ignorance on the effect of the substitution between commodities that
derived from the changes in relative prices (ibid., p.499).  

The substitution effect in consumption entered into the customs union theory through the
works of Meade (1956), Gehrel (1956 57), and Lipsey (1957) (cited in Lipsey, 1960,
p.501). Gehrel’s conclusion in favor of the gains rather than the losses of the customs
union is criticized by Lipsey (1960) because of taking into account two commodity case.   15
Lipsey (1960) states that in order to derive the valid conclusions on the customs union
theory it is necessary to consider at least three types of commodities (domestic commodity,
imports from partners, imports from the outside world). Additionally, Lipsey (1960)
proposes the distinction of inter country substitution that would embody trade creation and
trade diversion effects of Viner (1950), and inter commodity substitution that would derive
from the changes in relative prices.  His analysis  together with the analysis of Meade
(1956) lead Lipsey to conclude that “when only some tariffs are to be changed, welfare is
more likely to be raised if these tariffs are merely reduced than if they are completely
removed” (ibid., p.507). Lipsey also makes another  generalization1
 that relates the gains
from inter commodity substitution to the size of expenditure on previously mentioned
three classes of goods. From these generalizations, Lipsey (1960, p.508) concludes that
“the sort of countries who ought to form customs unions are those doing a high proportion
of their foreign trade with their union partner, and making a high proportion of their total
expenditure on domestic trade”.

Another extension on the Vinerian analysis came from the study of Dam (1963). Dam
(1963) interpretes the Viner’s trade diversion and  trade creation effects as the model of
production side and includes consumption effects to measure the overall impact of RIAs
together with the production effects. Accordingly,  the ratio of prices paid for domestic
goods to that for partner goods and the ratio of prices paid for partner goods to that for
non member goods will be changed by the formation of FTA, and “consumers will tend to
find prices of member goods cheaper, relative to the pre free trade area situation, than
either local goods or nonmember goods” (ibid., p.626). Hence, this will result in favorable
(substitution of member goods for local goods) and  unfavorable consumption effects
(substitution of member goods for nonmember goods). Dam (1963, p.628) concludes as
“… the smaller the range of goods imported from nonmember countries relative to the
range of goods imported from member countries, the  smaller the unfavorable and the
greater the favorable consumption effects”.

The study of Cooper and Massell (1965), on the other hand, derives the pure theory of the
customs union theory which is based on the Lipsey’s extension of the Vinerian trade
                                                
1
 This generalization derives from Lipsey’s doctoral thesis: Lipsey, R.G., 1958, “The theory of customs
unions: A general equilibrium analysis”, Unpublished Ph.D. thesis,  University of London.   16
creation and trade diversion analysis. The study rules out the effects like terms of trade and
economies of scale from the pure theory. By splitting the welfare effects of a CU into two
as “tariff reduction component” and “pure trade diversion component” (ibid., p.743),
authors states that the former component is the only source of any gain in consumers’
welfare in the integrated union. Accordingly, this component accounts for the consumption
effect introduced by Lipsey (1960) and the trade creation effect of Viner (1950). The
overall effect of the union will depend on the relative magnitudes of the two components in
which tariff reduction component represents the gain side, pure trade diversion represents
the welfare loss side of a CU. In the welfare analysis, the study concludes that since a CU
necessarily causes in trade diversion, as a result welfare loss, appropriate policy of non
preferential protection would result in better welfare effects relative to the customs union
option. The authors further criticizes the Viner’s  analysis taking into account customs
union as an acceptable policy option but not taking into account a tariff reduction policy. 

The study of Arndt (1968) starts from the ‘inferiority of the customs union relative to the
non preferential protection’ assertion suggested by Cooper and Massell (1965) and argues
that the argument is not valid due to not taking into account the effect of integration on the
terms of trade. With three country two goods model, the study concludes that two
countries acting together may gain in economic terms, relative to the case where one
country acts alone, due to the terms of trade effect of the union which result in a “net
improvement in welfare over any non preferential tariff situation” (ibid., p.976).  Kemp
and Wan (1976), on other hand, emphasizes the importance of the design of RIAs on the
expected outcomes. The study shows that the optimal tariff constructed so as to leave non
members’ trade unaffected would improve the welfare of member countries as well as the
welfare of world. The argument raised in Cooper and Massell (1965) is also critized by
Wonnacott and Wonnacott (1981). The study suggests  that small countries can gain from
the formation of regional integration in the presence of transport costs.  

With the advance of the new trade theory, the concepts of imperfect competition,
economies of scale and product differentiation has  become important determinants of
international trade. In this vein, Krugman (1991) studies the model consisting B identical
blocs and N identical countries, each producing one differentiated product. While transport   17
costs are not taken into account, the model is further based on the concept of natural
trading partners which states two countries as natural partners in case of high initial
volumes of bilateral trade and low distance between them. According to this setting, as the
number of blocs declines through further integration, each bloc starts to consume from the
share of the other blocs. The study finds the maximum number of blocs as three.

The extension of Krugman (1991) model comes from Frankel, Stein and Wei (1996). The
study emphasizes the role of transportation costs on determining the desirability of RIAs
and includes transport costs to the model of Krugman (1991). Accordingly, the magnitude
of these costs will determine the optimal level for the extent of regional integration. 

On the other hand, Panagariya (1998) offers an example in which the formation of a PTA
with a distant partner is superior relative to the  one with proximate partner. The author
states that the studies like Wonnacott and Wonnacott (1981) and Frankel et al. (1996) that
emphasize the importance of proximity or transport  costs on the formation of PTAs are
misleading due to their highly specific assumptions and/or selected variables of the
simulations.  Accordingly, all sources of cost (transportation costs, costs arising from
differences in technology/factor endowments) have equal significance for the trade flows. 

Goto and Hamada (1999) study the effects of regional integration under the assumptions of
constant tariffs and asymmetric bloc formation as an extension of the Krugman (1991)
framework which assumes symmetric blocs. The study  states that welfare first increases
with the expansion of the bloc, but when approximatley half of the world is participated
into this bloc, welfare starts to decrease with new members. 

LITERATURE REVIEW

LITERATURE REVIEW

The relationship between RIAs and globalization has been studied from different
perspectives throughout the literature. While Jacob Viner’s (1950) work on the Customs
Union was the first attempt of theorizing the welfare effects of RIAs, the following studies
like Lipsey (1960), Cooper and Massell (1965) were extensions of the Vinerian analysis

.
These studies significantly contributed to the development of this analysis. In the late
1980s, with the introduction of the New Trade Theory, several studies like Krugman
(1991) and Frankel et al. (1996) included new factors like economies of scale and product
differentiation in order to model regional economic integration. The 1990s, on the other
hand, witnessed the emergence of studies that emphasized the effects of regionalism on the
future multilateral trading system, like the ‘dynamic analysis’ of regional integration,
Bhagwati (1993). In a similar vein, the studies on  the political economy stance like Levy
(1994), Grossman and Helpman (1995) and Krishna (1998) provided significant insights
about RIAs and their effects on multilateral tariff liberalization.

Since there is a growing literature in regionalism debate, this chapter tries to survey some
of these studies through categorizing them into three subsections. The first section will
present a brief summary of selected studies that contributed to the theoretical development
of regionalism. The second section will try to enlist some of the literature that focused on
the relationship between regional economic integration and multilateral tariff liberalization,
and on the effects of regional integration on multilateral free trade. The final section, on
the other hand, will survey the literature studying the effects of regional economic
integration on member and non member countries.  


                                                
1
 Although classical economists like A.Smith (1776), Ricardo (1817) and McCulloch (1832) had mentioned
about trade diverting effects of of preferential commercial treaties, theory of economic integration dates back
to the 1940s that include the studies of de Beers (1941), Tinbergen (1945), Byé (1950) (Robson, 2000, p.8).
The study of Balassa (1961), on the other hand, was the first for the systematic analysis of this theory (cited
in Halıcıoğlu, 1996, p.4).

Structure of Regional Integration Agreements

Structure of Regional Integration Agreements

When the configuration of RIAs is taken into account, it is seen that the increasing number
of RIAs implies the networks of RIAs that include intra and inter continental members. It
is usually the case that one member of given RIA is also a member of another RIA. This   12
naturally results in overlapping RIAs and makes regional integration issue increasingly
more complex. The simplest form of RIAs is bilateral agreement that involves two member
countries. There are nearly 155 RIAs (covering goods and services) that are in force and
between two countries, recently. This number constitutes more than half of the RIAs that
are in force and notified to the WTO. The plurilateral agreements, on the other hand,
include more than two member countries. 

In the geographical context, while in most of the RIAs, member countries of the integration
are neighboring countries, some RIAs cover members  locating in different continents.
Examples of these inter continental RIAs include the US Israel FTA, Chile Japan FTA,
Peru China FTA. Although it does not fit into the above types of integration, the Asia
Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) that includes twenty one countries from four
continents. The more complex type of regional integration arises if one partner is itself an
RIA, like FTAs/CUs between the EU and several countries (Israel, Jordan, Mexico, Syria,
Turkey, etc.). EFTA and MERCOSUR are also involved  in such integration agreements.
Although EFTA SACU (2008) the only up to date example, it is expected that the trend
would let the emergence of several RIAs that involve the other RIAs as partners. For
example, the EU is negotiating the formation of FTA with MERCOSUR.

RIAs can also be classified according to the development levels of member countries as
North North, North South and South South agreements. In this kind of classification,
while “North” symbolizes developed countries, “South” symbolizes developing countries.
Hence, the first type of these agreements includes developed countries as members and its
subject area, that is its scope, tends to be more comprehensive than the other two
agreements. The European Community (EC) was the first example of such agreements.
The US Australia FTA that came into force in 2005 is, on the other hand, another example
of North North agreements. North South agreements,  like North American Free Trade
Area (NAFTA) and the Turkey EU customs union, include partnership of a developing
country(s) with a developed one(s). South South agreements, like Latin American Free
Trade Area (LAFTA) and Southern African CU (SACU), on the other hand, cover RIAs
that are established by developing countries. South South agreements are tend to be more
relax on the subject coverage and the degree of liberalization. 

REGIONAL INTEGRATION: MAJOR CONCEPTS

REGIONAL INTEGRATION: MAJOR CONCEPTS


While the globalization experience of the world has been evolving, on the other side,
nation states have been searching for the opportunities that would preserve their national
interests. Membership in regional economic integration is regarded as one of such
opportunities. Hence, regional economic integration is conceived as a way to gain
privileged situation within the specified boundaries. As it will be studied in the following
chapters, while preferential trade relations were mainly characterized by the colonial trade
links in the first wave of globalization, arrangements existing in the the second wave of
globalization have been supplemented by the legal environment of GATT/WTO system. In
this chapter, the basic concepts related to regional economic integration will be presented.
These concepts include the definition of regional integration, types of the regional
integration agreements (RIAs) and the structure of RIAs.

2.1 Definition of Regional Integration

What regional integration or regionalism means in economic sense should be the starting
point for understanding the overall concept of RIAs. In its dictionary meaning, regionalism
can be defined as a foreign economic policy that defines the national interests of a country
in terms of particular geographic areas. On the other hand, the WTO defines regionalism as
actions by governments to liberalize or facilitate  trade on a regional basis, sometimes
through free trade areas or custom unions.

Before to study types of regional integration, remark on the concepts of regionalism and
regionalization would be beneficial. Such remark will help further to clarify the meaning of
regionalism. While regionalization is a process mainly driven by market forces of trade and
investment flows, regionalism derives from state led policies of cooperation and
intergovernmental treaties (Gavin & van Langenhove, 2003, p.280). Differently, Ravenhill
(2005, p.117) distinguishes regionalism as a formal process of intergovernmental   9
cooperation between two or more countries, and regionalization as the growth of economic
interdependence within the specified geographical area.